Swain's Stuffed Bakery Menu
Where decadence lives in every slice and sweet treat to feed your soul. Cakes are also available by the slice at Swain's Stuffed Bakery or Swain's Cut Restaurant located right next door to our bakery.
Small Bites and Flights
Indulge and stop by for a sample small bite flight of our most popular desserts !
Mini Cakes Flight Box
This 7 piece sample "Flight" box is a the mini cakes are samples of our most popular stuffed cakes on a rotating basis. Choices include Vanilla, caramel, coconut, key lime -coconut, chocolate, heath bar, strawberry, lemon, red-velvet, carrot and much more...
$18
Min Cakes
Available in both the Bakery and Swains' Restaurant, the mini cakes are samples of our most popular stuffed cakes on a rotating basis. Choices include Vanilla, caramel, coconut, key lime -coconut, chocolate, heath bar, strawberry, lemon, red-velvet, carrot and much more...
$2.95
Mini Pies
Can't choose just one flavor? No Worries, stop in to mix and match our 3" mini versions of your favorites or try them all! Great for parties and events too.
$2.95
Mini Cheesecakes 3"
We offer mini cheesecakes so you can mix and match your favorite flavors! Great for parties and events !
$12
Stuffed Cakes and Frosted Creations
Featuring our Signature Stuffed Cakes and our take on some traditional cake favorites.
Stuffed Coconut Cake
Our Signature Item ! A handmade combination of moist cake, sweet coconut, and a Key Lime Pie all wrapped up in one special place. We start with a scratch baked white cake, top it with cream cheese frosting, toasted coconut and stuff it with a key lime pie. It's worth the trip !!!
Small
$20
Large
$55
Blueberry Cheesecake Stuffed Lemon Cake
Sweet and simple.... We start with a fresh blueberry cheesecake and layer it inside fresh double stacked lemon cake with internal blueberry drizzles.
Small
$30
Large
$60
Peanut Butter Pie Stuffed Chocolate Cake
Our peanut butter pie sandwiched in dark chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and chocolate butter cream frosting
Small
$30
Large
$60
Cheesecake Stuffed Carrot Cake
Brown-sugar cheesecake stuffed in carrot cake with a cream cheese frosting
Small
$30
Large
$60
Heath Bar Cloud Cake
A Swains Restaurant best seller. Multiple layers of Chocolate and caramel cakes layered with chocolate and caramel mouse, English toffee, caramel and chocolate ganache with whipped cream icing and crushed Heath bar
Small
$20
Large
$45
Chocolate Mudslide Cake
Dark Chocolate cake soaked in Baileys Irish Cream and Kahlua layered with Bailey's Mousse and whipped chocolate cream icing
Small
$25
Large
$55
Chocolate Madness Cake
Chocolate cake layered with chocolate mousse with a chocolate buttercream icing and covered in chocolate ganache.
Small
$20
Large
$45
Strawberry Cake
Strawberry cake layered with fresh strawberry compote and strawberry mousse. With a whip cream frosting
Small
$20
Large
$45
Coconut Cake
Layers of coconut cake with coconut cream cheese frosting and fresh shaved coconut
Small
$15
Large
$40
Traditional Tiramisu
Layers of lady finger soaked in Kahlua and espresso layered with mascarpone cream topped with fresh whipped cream and Brut cocoa powder
Slice
$11
1/2 tray up to 12 PPL
$80
Fill Tray up to 20 PPL
$140
Daily Specialty Tiramisu
Call for the daily flavor: Lemon, Blueberry-Lemon, Strawberry and Chocolate
Slice
$11
1/2 tray up to 12 PPL
$80
Fill Tray up to 20 PPL
$140
Pies
All pies are prepared fresh in house daily. Don't miss out on the famous Swain's Key Lime Pie !!
Key Lime Pie
Prepared using a traditional 100-year-old family recipe straight from the Florida Keys! We use REAL fresh squeezed Key Limes .
$18
Chocolate covered Key Lime Pie
Yes! We have it. Keylime pie in a chocolate cookie crust topped with chocolate ganache and whipped cream
$22
Coconut Cream Pie
Swain's own secret recipe. This is a decadent pie that needs to beat every summer gathering.
$20
Coconut Macaroon Pie
Our famous coconut cream pie in a chocolate cookie crust topped with chocolate ganache toasted coconut and whipped cream.
$20
Peanut Butter Pie
A creamy delight of whipped peanut butter in a chocolate crust topped with whipped cream
$20
Banana Cream Pie
A light fluffy version of banana pudding in a vanilla wafer crust topped with whipped cream and yes more vanilla wafers
$20
Chocolate Mousse Pie
Dark Chocolate Mousse in a chocolate crust topped with chocolate ganache and whipped cream
$20
Apple Pie (Seasonal)
Seasonal Apples picked in the fall on our annual Mother Daughter Apple Picking in the Blue Ridge Mountains.
Pecan Pie (Seasonal)
We don't pick them, but we know who does. We use select pecans to make these pies in the fall and winter season
Cheesecakes
Blueberry Cheesecake
Topped with sugared blueberries
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$30
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Chocolate Cheesecake
Rich dark chocolate topped with chocolate ganache and chocolate twirls
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$30
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Cookies N' Cream Cheesecake
Oreo cookie crust and topped with crushed Oreos and white chocolate
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$60
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Lemon Cheesecake
topped with a tangy lemon curd and candied lemon peel
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$30
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Strawberry Cheesecake
Topped with fresh whipped cream and glazed strawberries
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$30
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Turtle Cheesecake
Tuxedo cheesecake topped with Caramel, Chocolate and candies pecans
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$30
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
creamy Italian style cheesecake
Slice
$10
Small 6"
$30
Medium 9"
$60
Large 12"
$80
Cookies and Brownies
A diverse range of flavorful dishes which are all sourced daily and locally
Brownies
Turtle, Triple Chocolate Fudge, Heathbar, Dubai and more....
$7
Birthday Cake Frosting Stuffed Sugar Cookies
We took a classic, buttery sugar cookie and stuffed it to the brim with rich, creamy birthday cake frosting
Single
$2.95
Bakers Dozen Box
$18
Brownie Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies
Yes, you can have the best of both worlds when you stuff a brownie inside a chocolate chip cookie.
Single
$2.95
Bakers Dozen Box
$18
Strawberry Jelly Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies
A childhood classic, reimagined. We’ve taken our rich, soft-baked peanut butter cookies and stuffed them with a generous, gooey center of sweet strawberry jelly.
Single
$2.95
Bakers Dozen Box
$18
Chocolate Chip Cookies
There’s a reason this is a classic. We bake our chocolate chip cookies to golden-brown perfection
Single
$2.95
Bakers Dozen Box
$18